Sandra Pope
July 29, 2026 · Experience July 29, 2026
Left a mess in the car
The tire work was fine, but they left grease on the door handle and the floor mat. Not what I expect from a professional shop.
19 reviews
- Verified customer
- Verified customer
Rick Jones
June 14, 2026 · Experience June 14, 2026
Top notch tire work
I’ve been coming here for years and they always treat me right. Whether it's a simple flat repair or new tires, the quality is always there.
- Verified customer
Thomas Reyes
May 14, 2026 · Experience May 14, 2026
Solid work on my truck
Got a set of all-terrain tires and they are performing well. Professional service and clean shop. A bit of a wait, but worth it.
- Verified customer
Erich Metz
May 2, 2026 · Experience May 2, 2026
Professional alignment service
My truck was pulling to the left and they fixed it fast. The ride is much smoother now. Really satisfied with the work.
- Verified customer
John Greska
February 25, 2026 · Experience February 25, 2026
Professional and fast
Great spot in Bonifay. They had me in and out with a fresh set of tires in under an hour. Very professional team and reasonable rates.
- Verified customer
Denise Cabrera
December 12, 2025 · Experience December 12, 2025
Great shop and honest service
Highly recommend Allstar. They are always straight with you about what you need and what can wait. Rare to find that kind of honesty.
- Verified customer
Barbara Farina
November 23, 2025 · Experience November 23, 2025
It was okay
They did the job, but it took longer than they said it would. The tires are fine, just not the most efficient experience I’ve had.
- Verified customer
Debra Leone
November 18, 2025 · Experience November 18, 2025
Best tire shop in town
They always take good care of my sedan. Honest about what I actually need and never pushy. Best tire shop in the area for sure.
- Verified customer
Design Eagles
October 6, 2025 · Experience October 6, 2025
Poor communication on repair
They didn't call me when the car was finished. I had to call them three times just to find out if it was ready to pick up.
- Verified customer
Pamela Knight
September 30, 2025 · Experience September 30, 2025
Alignment wasn't done right
Had to take it back twice because the car was still pulling to the right after the alignment. Very annoying to deal with the repeat trips.
- Verified customer
Jay Tass
September 19, 2025 · Experience September 19, 2025
Excellent service and quality
I had a great experience here. The staff was super helpful and clearly takes pride in their work. Everything was done correctly the first time.
- Verified customer
Dave Richard
July 27, 2025 · Experience July 27, 2025
Saved the day with new tires
Came in with a blown tire and they had the perfect replacement in stock. Amazing speed and very fair pricing for the emergency repair.
- Verified customer
Peter Vance
May 20, 2025 · Experience May 20, 2025
Good service, fair pricing
Needed a quick rotation and balance. The guys were friendly and got it done properly. Solid choice if you're in town.
- Verified customer
Timothy Joley
April 23, 2025 · Experience April 23, 2025
Terrible experience, would not recommend
Scheduled an appointment and still waited three hours. They didn't even apologize for the delay. Will never come back to this tire shop.
- Verified customer
James Miller
April 1, 2025 · Experience April 1, 2025
Always consistent service
I go here for all my tire rotations. They are fast, thorough, and always friendly. It’s hard to find a local shop that consistently performs well.
- Verified customer
Liz Bobbie
December 11, 2024 · Experience December 11, 2024
Quick tire swap
Had a flat and they got me back on the road in no time. Friendly and fair price too. Highly recommend these guys.
- Verified customer
Jered Hess
October 16, 2024 · Experience October 16, 2024
Good tires, long wait
Great selection of tires and very helpful advice. Just be prepared to wait a while, they seem to be very popular in Bonifay.
- Verified customer
Emily Campbell
September 17, 2024 · Experience September 17, 2024
Rude staff and overpriced
They were incredibly rude when I asked about a warranty claim on my tires. Then they tried to charge me for labor on top of it. Stay away.
- Verified customer
Brian Whitaker
August 30, 2024 · Experience August 30, 2024
Friendly and helpful shop
I really appreciate their focus on safety. They checked my brakes while swapping my tires and let me know I had some life left, rather than pushing a sale.