American Classic Car Sales

4.5Great · 11 reviews · 11 verifiedUnclaimed

11 reviews

  • Patricia Nguyen

    July 19, 2026 · Experience July 19, 2026

    Verified customer

    Total waste of time

    They advertised a car that wasn't even on the lot. Drove two hours for nothing. Nobody apologized or seemed to care about my time. Definitely won't be back.

  • Barbara Lemons

    June 7, 2026 · Experience June 7, 2026

    Verified customer

    Class act dealership

    Found the perfect ride for my collection. The staff really knows their stuff and didn't try to rush me. I was impressed by the care they put into these cars.

  • Ryan Caldwell

    April 5, 2026 · Experience April 5, 2026

    Verified customer

    Solid selection

    Nice variety of classic cars. The prices are on the higher side but the condition of the cars justifies it. I ended up buying a cool old sedan.

  • Charles Dunn

    April 3, 2026 · Experience April 3, 2026

    Verified customer

    Professional team

    I was hesitant to buy a car like this online but they sent me tons of detailed photos. When I arrived in person, the car was exactly as described.

  • Cindy Munley

    February 13, 2026 · Experience February 13, 2026

    Verified customer

    Best in Sarasota

    Stopped by just to browse and ended up falling in love with a convertible. The guys there are super knowledgeable and made the finance part quick.

  • Brian Orlick

    February 1, 2026 · Experience February 1, 2026

    Verified customer

    Top notch cars

    Selection here is amazing for any collector. I visited three times before pulling the trigger. Each time the staff was helpful and never acted pushy at all.

  • Mindy Thaler

    January 5, 2026 · Experience January 5, 2026

    Verified customer

    Friendly and helpful

    These guys made buying a classic car easy. They helped with all the paperwork and even arranged the transport for me. Really happy with my new vehicle.

  • James Oneavatar

    October 19, 2025 · Experience October 19, 2025

    Verified customer

    Quality inventory

    The showroom is clean and the cars look great. I went in for a specific model and they walked me through its history. Good experience overall.

  • Patrick Osborne

    February 7, 2025 · Experience February 7, 2025

    Verified customer

    Excellent service

    Had an issue with a trim piece after I got home, and they actually mailed me a replacement part for free. Real stand up people here.

  • Rodney Rubright

    December 26, 2024 · Experience December 26, 2024

    Verified customer

    Great experience

    Loved the transparency here. They showed me the service records without me even asking. Really feels like they care about their reputation.

  • Synthia Horvath

    August 28, 2024 · Experience August 28, 2024

    Verified customer

    Dream car purchase

    Had my eyes on a vintage mustang for a while. Found it here and the condition was even better than the pictures showed. Really smooth process from start to finish.