Pauline Pfeffer
August 8, 2026 · Experience August 8, 2026
Wonderful experience all around
They made buying my car so easy. Everyone was kind and the financing didn't take nearly as long as I expected.
20 reviews
- Verified customer
- Verified customer
Kathryn Beltran
June 15, 2026 · Experience June 15, 2026
Avoid this dealership
They sold me a lemon and wouldn't return my calls after I signed the papers. Dishonest business practices all around. Total waste of time.
- Verified customer
Zuzi Price
January 28, 2026 · Experience January 28, 2026
Average cars and long wait
They have a lot of options, but it took hours to get through the financing. Decent cars, just be prepared to spend the day here.
- Verified customer
Raha Mahboobi
December 22, 2025 · Experience December 22, 2025
Professionalism at its best
The team at American Motors is excellent. They are transparent and made sure I felt confident in my purchase.
- Verified customer
Kimberly Tran
December 22, 2025 · Experience December 22, 2025
Terrible customer service
Had an issue with the brakes the day after I bought the car. They refused to even look at it without a fee. Absolutely avoid this place.
- Verified customer
Anita Hermann
December 1, 2025 · Experience December 1, 2025
Quick and easy transaction
I had a great time working with the team here. Very professional and the paperwork was done in record time.
- Verified customer
Nathan Ruiz
October 23, 2025 · Experience October 23, 2025
Great service and great prices
I've been to many dealers but this was the best one by far. Clear pricing and very helpful staff. I'll be back for sure.
- Verified customer
Jacob Sterling
September 17, 2025 · Experience September 17, 2025
Simple and honest car buying
No pressure sales. I felt very comfortable throughout the whole process and I really appreciated the transparency from the team.
- Verified customer
Driver
September 4, 2025 · Experience September 4, 2025
Best car buying experience
Everyone was friendly and the car was priced fairly. No hidden fees or surprises at the end. Highly recommend for anyone in Sarasota.
- Verified customer
Nicholas Reed
March 7, 2025 · Experience March 7, 2025
Great team in Sarasota
Professional service from start to finish. I felt like they genuinely cared about getting me a good deal. Very happy with the car.
- Verified customer
Maria Sanchez
February 22, 2025 · Experience February 22, 2025
Very happy with the deal
Got a great value on my trade-in and a good price on my new car. I'll definitely be recommending them to all my friends.
- Verified customer
Dave Richard
January 27, 2025 · Experience January 27, 2025
Felt misled by sales
The salesperson swore the car was a one-owner vehicle, but I found out later it had three owners. Check the Carfax yourself first.
- Verified customer
Ed Raus
January 26, 2025 · Experience January 26, 2025
Decent car, just a bit of a wait
Good inventory, but the place was crowded and it took a while to get help. Once they helped me, the process was fine.
- Verified customer
Joe Tierno
January 12, 2025 · Experience January 12, 2025
Reliable dealer in Sarasota
I always buy my work vehicles here. They have a great selection and their staff is always straight with me on prices.
- Verified customer
Marilyn Hobbs
November 20, 2024 · Experience November 20, 2024
Great experience with my SUV
I'm loving my new ride. Thanks to Joe for helping me with the financing. It was all very smooth and easy to understand.
- Verified customer
The Outlaw Olive
October 31, 2024 · Experience October 31, 2024
Fantastic customer service
I wasn't sure what I wanted, but the sales team was very patient. I walked away with a car I love and at a price I could afford.
- Verified customer
Robert Hayes
October 15, 2024 · Experience October 15, 2024
Amazing selection of trucks
I was looking for a specific truck and they had exactly what I needed. Fair trade-in price and very helpful sales staff.
- Verified customer
Janet Ocampo
October 3, 2024 · Experience October 3, 2024
Avoid these guys if you can
I had nothing but trouble with the car I bought from them. They claimed it was inspected, but it had major issues within a month.
- Verified customer
Nicole Baptiste
October 2, 2024 · Experience October 2, 2024
Easiest trade in ever
I traded in my old sedan and they made it super easy. Fair value and I walked away with a newer SUV the same day.
- Verified customer
Kevin Robinson
September 16, 2024 · Experience September 16, 2024
Amazing selection of trucks
Found a great work truck for my business. The price was fair and the sales process was quick. Will definitely come back for another.