Rose Taylor
June 29, 2026 · Experience June 29, 2026
Incredible communication and local knowledge
Amy kept us updated every single day of the transaction. She even recommended a great local contractor.
Amy Puto - Upper/Middle FL Keys Real Estate
4.4Great · 19 reviews · 19 verifiedClaimed profile
19 reviews
- Verified customer
- Verified customer
Brian Burgee
May 24, 2026 · Experience May 24, 2026
The best in the Keys
Amy helped us find our vacation home in Marathon. She knows every street and gave us the real scoop on insurance costs.
- Verified customer
Andrew Castillo
May 8, 2026 · Experience May 8, 2026
Frustrating lack of follow-up
She started strong but then seemed to lose interest once things hit a snag in the inspection phase.
- Verified customer
Robert Dorr
May 1, 2026 · Experience May 1, 2026
Five star agent
Very personable and clearly loves what she does. Made the whole process feel like a walk in the park.
- Verified customer
Janet Ocampo
March 9, 2026 · Experience March 9, 2026
Solid partner for buying a home
She was patient and showed us many houses before we found 'the one.' Always professional and kind.
- Verified customer
Steven Alvarez
February 8, 2026 · Experience February 8, 2026
Expert on Marathon real estate
We wouldn't have navigated the closing process without her. She saved us from a bad deal with a property inspection issue.
- Verified customer
Donald Lizotte
January 6, 2026 · Experience January 6, 2026
Knowledgeable agent, honest advice
She told us the hard truth about the repair costs needed for a property, which actually saved us money.
- Verified customer
David Coleman
November 25, 2025 · Experience November 25, 2025
Fair, but missed some details
She found us a great spot, but missed a few small things in the disclosure documents. Otherwise nice to work with.
- Verified customer
Timothy Joley
November 11, 2025 · Experience November 11, 2025
Professional, kind, and efficient
We felt very secure with Amy handling our money and paperwork. Trustworthy to the core.
- Verified customer
Debra Whisanant
October 1, 2025 · Experience October 1, 2025
Decent agent but busy
Amy is very knowledgeable but she is so busy it is hard to get a call back sometimes. Good advice though.
- Verified customer
Nancy J. Walker
July 23, 2025 · Experience July 23, 2025
Very helpful with listing our home
Good staging advice. We sold our place in three weeks. Only minor nitpick is the scheduling of showings was hectic.
- Verified customer
Figueroa-Robbins
July 1, 2025 · Experience July 1, 2025
Highly professional and skilled
Amy helped me list my condo. It was sold in record time thanks to her marketing plan.
- Verified customer
Linda Carter
June 10, 2025 · Experience June 10, 2025
Helpful but hard to reach
I had trouble getting through on the phone during peak hours. Great advice once you get a hold of her though.
- Verified customer
Ronald Guerrero
June 5, 2025 · Experience June 5, 2025
Outstanding service and results
Professional and honest. She didn't try to sugarcoat the market conditions for us, which we really appreciated.
- Verified customer
Daniel Eckert
April 29, 2025 · Experience April 29, 2025
Super responsive and helpful
Even after the sale, she sent us lists of good plumbers and landscapers. She really goes above and beyond.
- Verified customer
Thomas Reyes
January 27, 2025 · Experience January 27, 2025
Absolutely fantastic agent
She helped us navigate the confusing local property tax rules. You won't find a better advocate in the Keys.
- Verified customer
Patricia Nguyen
November 19, 2024 · Experience November 19, 2024
Amy is the best!
She knows everything about Keys regulations. Without her, we wouldn't have known about the storm ratings.
- Verified customer
John Deyo
October 18, 2024 · Experience October 18, 2024
Smooth sailing for first time buyers
She held our hand through the entire buying process. We felt so comfortable buying our first property.
- Verified customer
Aaron Whitehead
September 12, 2024 · Experience September 12, 2024
Flawless real estate transaction
We were worried about the closing, but Amy made it look simple. Highly recommend her services.