Not what I expected
Review of Carlo's Bakery by Denise Newbold · July 30, 2025
2/5
The cake I ordered for my anniversary was dry. For the price I paid, I expected much higher quality. Very disappointed in the final product.
More reviews of Carlo's Bakery
- Verified customer
Rodney Rubright
August 11, 2026 · Experience August 11, 2026
Reliable spot
Very busy place but the staff stays friendly. Got a dozen cookies for the office and they were a hit with everyone. Good experience.
- Verified customer
Jerry Sampson
August 10, 2026 · Experience August 10, 2026
Delicious as always
Stopped in for some lobster tails and they did not disappoint. Flaky and the cream inside was perfect. Definitely coming back soon.
- Verified customer
Marie Dupont
May 18, 2026 · Experience May 18, 2026
Best treats in Hoboken
I always grab a black and white cookie when I am in the area. They are soft and perfect. The staff is always fast even when it is packed.
- Verified customer
Julie Ferraro
May 13, 2026 · Experience May 13, 2026
Solid neighborhood bakery
I stop by here once a week for fresh bread. It is always warm and smells like heaven. A bit crowded but it is worth the trek.