Sandra Pope
July 3, 2026 · Experience July 3, 2026
Highly recommended antique store
Jerry is very knowledgeable and helped me appraise a few things. Such a friendly atmosphere and always something new to look at on the shelves.
14 reviews
- Verified customer
- Verified customer
Brian Burgee
June 18, 2026 · Experience June 18, 2026
Stunning antiques and great service
Samuel was so helpful identifying some old coins for me. The shop is beautiful and the staff is very knowledgeable about local history.
- Verified customer
Jeffrey Hobbs
April 4, 2026 · Experience April 4, 2026
A bit pricey but nice quality
Jay has some lovely stuff, but the prices are quite high. Nice to browse, but be prepared to spend if you actually want to buy something.
- Verified customer
Beth Covarrubias
March 29, 2026 · Experience March 29, 2026
Great customer service and inventory
Jeffrey was very helpful and pleasant to work with. He helped me find the right furniture piece for my home and even arranged delivery.
- Verified customer
Samuel Grauer
February 11, 2026 · Experience February 11, 2026
Beautiful shop with rare finds
Susan showed me some incredible art pieces today. Every time I visit this place, I find something unique and interesting. Truly a gem on the island.
- Verified customer
Barbara Lemons
February 4, 2026 · Experience February 4, 2026
The place to find rare treasures
Scott helped me find a rare vase for my collection. Very knowledgeable staff and they ship items securely. So glad I found this place.
- Verified customer
Angela Whitlock
August 21, 2025 · Experience August 21, 2025
My favorite shop in town
Gloria is the best! She always knows exactly what I'm looking for. The quality of items they carry here is just unmatched by anyone else.
- Verified customer
Susan Delgado
August 11, 2025 · Experience August 11, 2025
Extremely rude service
Angela was very dismissive when I asked about a piece of jewelry. I felt like I was bothering her by being in the shop. Won't be back.
- Verified customer
Cheryl Novak
July 22, 2025 · Experience July 22, 2025
Great antiques, nice staff
Aaron helped me with some silver pieces. Good variety of items, friendly atmosphere. A bit crowded on the weekends, but worth the visit.
- Verified customer
Jerry Sampson
July 1, 2025 · Experience July 1, 2025
Beautiful shop, very welcoming
Barbara made my visit today so pleasant. The store is well organized and everything is displayed beautifully. Definitely worth a visit if you are visiting.
- Verified customer
Jay Tass
May 1, 2025 · Experience May 1, 2025
Wonderful experience at Islander Trading
Cheryl was super friendly and helpful. I love the vibe of the store and will definitely make this a regular stop whenever I visit Sanibel.
- Verified customer
Gloria Banks
March 3, 2025 · Experience March 3, 2025
So many treasures to find
Sandra helped me pick out a gift for my wife. The selection is huge, and they really take the time to explain the provenance of the items.
- Verified customer
Scott Rendon
February 13, 2025 · Experience February 13, 2025
Such a lovely antique store
Beth always has the best inventory. I found some old maps today that were exactly what I needed. Everything is authentic and priced fairly.
- Verified customer
Aaron Ross
January 19, 2025 · Experience January 19, 2025
Good store, but service was slow
Nancy was friendly enough, but it took way too long to get checked out. They had some cool items, but the staffing levels seemed a bit low.