Great place, great people
Review of Key Colony Beach Motel by Paul Mendoza · June 23, 2026
5/5
Such a lovely property. Everything was clean and it felt very safe. Can't wait to visit the area again soon.
More reviews of Key Colony Beach Motel
- Verified customer
Jose Figueroa
July 2, 2026 · Experience July 2, 2026
Hidden gem in the Keys
Perfect little motel. It’s quiet, clean, and the staff makes you feel right at home. We will definitely be back.
- Verified customer
Thomas Reyes
March 17, 2026 · Experience March 17, 2026
Classic Florida Keys experience
Loved the atmosphere here. It has that old-school charm but with modern amenities like fast Wi-Fi and updated showers.
- Verified customer
Barbara Farina
January 22, 2026 · Experience January 22, 2026
Nice quiet place to rest
The grounds are beautiful and well kept. It's very quiet at night which is a huge plus for us light sleepers.
- Verified customer
Samuel Wexler
January 6, 2026 · Experience January 6, 2026
Average stay for the price
The location is fantastic, but the furniture in the room is quite outdated and the bathroom sink leaked a bit.