Key Colony Beach Realty, Inc.

3.6Average · 10 reviews · 10 verifiedUnclaimed

10 reviews

  • Clint Reid Sr

    February 15, 2026 · Experience February 15, 2026

    Verified customer

    Professional team

    Everything went off without a hitch. They handled the contract and inspection perfectly. Highly recommend their agency.

  • Connie Melendy

    November 2, 2025 · Experience November 2, 2025

    Verified customer

    Excellent service

    Managed our condo rental for three years. Never had a vacancy issue and they handle all the maintenance requests quickly.

  • Josephq Knick

    September 8, 2025 · Experience September 8, 2025

    Verified customer

    Good local knowledge

    Really know the Key Colony area well. Helped us navigate a tricky closing without any major stress.

  • Figueroa-Robbins

    September 3, 2025 · Experience September 3, 2025

    Verified customer

    Okay, but busy

    They have great inventory but it feels like they have too many clients to give much individual attention sometimes.

  • Adam Kessler

    August 3, 2025 · Experience August 3, 2025

    Verified customer

    Best island realtors

    They helped us find the perfect vacation home. Sarah was patient and showed us a dozen places until we found the one.

  • Susan Delgado

    February 11, 2025 · Experience February 11, 2025

    Verified customer

    Decent staff

    Had a few questions about the lease and it took a few days to get an answer. The team is friendly enough though.

  • Evelyn Marsh

    December 19, 2024 · Experience December 19, 2024

    Verified customer

    Highly recommended

    Bought our second home through them. Seamless transaction from start to finish. Everything was transparent and handled well.

  • Kyle R. Matthews

    December 12, 2024 · Experience December 12, 2024

    Verified customer

    Poor communication

    We kept waiting for updates on our rental property listing. Felt like we were constantly chasing them for info.

  • Kris Tyler

    October 5, 2024 · Experience October 5, 2024

    Verified customer

    Average experience

    The house was nice but the paperwork took way longer than expected. Staff was nice but the process seemed slow.

  • Beth Hartstein

    September 12, 2024 · Experience September 12, 2024

    Verified customer

    Waste of time

    Showed up for a scheduled viewing and the agent never arrived. No call, no email. Extremely unprofessional behavior.