Emily Campbell
August 14, 2026 · Experience August 14, 2026
Long lines, only one cashier
Every time I visit on Saturday, the lines are wrapping around the store. They need to open more registers when it gets busy.
18 reviews
- Verified customer
- Verified customer
Debra Whisanant
August 13, 2026 · Experience August 13, 2026
Produce section was rotten
Bought several bags of spinach and berries, and everything was spoiled within a day. Very disappointing quality control recently.
- Verified customer
Michael Pisano
July 14, 2026 · Experience July 14, 2026
Excellent selection for a small store
I'm always surprised by what I find here. Fresh bread, good produce, and the staff is always willing to help carry stuff to the car.
- Verified customer
Erich Metz
February 20, 2026 · Experience February 20, 2026
Best grocery store in town
Fresh produce and always friendly staff. The meat counter is excellent and they always have what I need for the week.
- Verified customer
Louis Monacello
January 29, 2026 · Experience January 29, 2026
Great meat department
The butcher is very knowledgeable and can prep anything I ask for. Best steaks in Mayo, hands down.
- Verified customer
Matthew Sullivan
January 18, 2026 · Experience January 18, 2026
Great prices, very clean
Been shopping here for years and it's always consistent. They do a great job keeping the store looking good and everything well-stocked.
- Verified customer
Benjamin Trask
November 4, 2025 · Experience November 4, 2025
Good overall experience
Very convenient for quick trips. Employees are usually quick to assist. Prices are fair, especially for a shop this size.
- Verified customer
Stan Kurpiel
August 22, 2025 · Experience August 22, 2025
My favorite neighborhood spot
Always fresh, always friendly, and the prices are better than the bigger stores. Definitely worth supporting this business.
- Verified customer
Jonathan Meyers
May 27, 2025 · Experience May 27, 2025
Quick and easy shopping
I can get in and out really fast. Shelves are always stocked and the prices are very competitive for the area.
- Verified customer
Aaron Whitehead
May 12, 2025 · Experience May 12, 2025
Consistent quality and price
Really happy with the variety of items available. It's so much easier shopping here than going to the massive superstores out of town.
- Verified customer
Barbara Lemons
April 24, 2025 · Experience April 24, 2025
Love this local shop
Always helpful employees and clean aisles. It's my go-to place for all my weekly groceries.
- Verified customer
Connie Melendy
March 18, 2025 · Experience March 18, 2025
Such a convenient grocery store
Love Thriftway! The staff is so helpful and the store is always neat and organized. Makes weekly shopping very easy.
- Verified customer
Diane Oyelaran
January 29, 2025 · Experience January 29, 2025
Average experience today
They were out of a couple basic items I needed, but the staff was friendly as usual. Not a bad place overall.
- Verified customer
John Knapek
January 22, 2025 · Experience January 22, 2025
Love the small town vibe
Staff remembers you and they are always cheerful. Makes grocery shopping actually enjoyable. Keep up the good work!
- Verified customer
Gary James
January 20, 2025 · Experience January 20, 2025
Good local store
Helpful employees and decent prices. It's nice having this close by, though I wish they had a bit more selection on specialty cheeses.
- Verified customer
Mark Sullivan
January 18, 2025 · Experience January 18, 2025
Best service in Mayo
Friendly staff, fair prices, and clean aisles. What more can you ask for? Highly recommend stopping by for your weekly shopping.
- Verified customer
Deb McCall
January 13, 2025 · Experience January 13, 2025
Good store, decent variety
Solid little shop with everything you'd expect. A bit limited on some specialty organic items, but otherwise very reliable and clean.
- Verified customer
Christopher Geist
October 22, 2024 · Experience October 22, 2024
Fantastic customer service
Every time I walk in, they say hello. Makes a big difference compared to those big chain supermarkets. Very happy customer.