Disappointed with appraisal offer
Review of West Bay Trading Co by Sammy Sallam · August 5, 2026
2/5
I brought in some coins and felt the offer was way below market value. Left feeling a bit frustrated.
More reviews of West Bay Trading Co
- Verified customer
Christina Boyle
August 2, 2026 · Experience August 2, 2026
Great shop, very professional
Extremely helpful team. They helped me evaluate my collection with total honesty and transparency.
- Verified customer
Greg Leathers
June 1, 2026 · Experience June 1, 2026
Knowledgeable and reliable dealers
Been a customer for years. Always honest about the condition of the coins and never pushy.
- Verified customer
Design Eagles
March 31, 2026 · Experience March 31, 2026
Very trustworthy local coin shop
I’ve been here a few times now and always get a great deal. They really know their stuff here.
- Verified customer
Nancy Kowalski
March 20, 2026 · Experience March 20, 2026
Honest traders and great stock
Very fair and professional. I always feel confident buying from them. Really appreciate their expertise.