Rude and incompetent staff
Review of Atlantic Toyota by Tyler Nash · March 17, 2026
1/5
Went in for a simple fix and they tried to upsell me on three things I didn't need. When I refused, they were extremely condescending.
More reviews of Atlantic Toyota
- Verified customer
Steven Maguire
August 9, 2026 · Experience August 9, 2026
Top-tier Toyota support
Amazing service and genuine parts. I wouldn't take my Toyota anywhere else in West Islip. The staff is always friendly and super helpful.
- Verified customer
Pamela Knight
July 26, 2026 · Experience July 26, 2026
Always great service
I've been coming here for years for maintenance on my Highlander. Never had an issue with parts availability or scheduling. Keep it up!
- Verified customer
Jacob Moore
June 20, 2026 · Experience June 20, 2026
Solid team and good parts
They always have the parts I need in stock. The service desk is usually busy, but the techs are thorough and get the job done right.
- Verified customer
Zachary Pruitt
May 29, 2026 · Experience May 29, 2026
Excellent service department
Brought my Corolla in for a brake job. They got me a shuttle ride home and finished the work well before the promised time. Highly satisfied.