Steven Maguire
August 9, 2026 · Experience August 9, 2026
Top-tier Toyota support
Amazing service and genuine parts. I wouldn't take my Toyota anywhere else in West Islip. The staff is always friendly and super helpful.
18 reviews
- Verified customer
- Verified customer
Pamela Knight
July 26, 2026 · Experience July 26, 2026
Always great service
I've been coming here for years for maintenance on my Highlander. Never had an issue with parts availability or scheduling. Keep it up!
- Verified customer
Jacob Moore
June 20, 2026 · Experience June 20, 2026
Solid team and good parts
They always have the parts I need in stock. The service desk is usually busy, but the techs are thorough and get the job done right.
- Verified customer
Zachary Pruitt
May 29, 2026 · Experience May 29, 2026
Excellent service department
Brought my Corolla in for a brake job. They got me a shuttle ride home and finished the work well before the promised time. Highly satisfied.
- Verified customer
Tyler Nash
March 17, 2026 · Experience March 17, 2026
Rude and incompetent staff
Went in for a simple fix and they tried to upsell me on three things I didn't need. When I refused, they were extremely condescending.
- Verified customer
Cindy Munley
March 8, 2026 · Experience March 8, 2026
Reliable and efficient
I trust this team with my vehicle. Every time I visit for an oil change or tire rotation, they are honest and quick with the service.
- Verified customer
Julie Ferraro
February 20, 2026 · Experience February 20, 2026
Quick part replacement
My mirror needed to be replaced and they had it ready the same day. Saved me a lot of trouble! Very impressed with their parts department.
- Verified customer
Carlos Perez
January 11, 2026 · Experience January 11, 2026
Professionalism at its finest
Atlantic Toyota has a great culture. Everyone from the front desk to the mechanics is helpful and clearly cares about getting things right for the customer.
- Verified customer
Patrick Osborne
December 2, 2025 · Experience December 2, 2025
Seamless new truck purchase
Bought a Tundra and the whole process was great. Sales rep Mark made sure I got all the incentives I was eligible for.
- Verified customer
Melissa Kane
November 27, 2025 · Experience November 27, 2025
Great customer experience
Everyone at Atlantic Toyota is professional and kind. My car was serviced efficiently and the lobby was well stocked with coffee and Wi-Fi.
- Verified customer
James Oneavatar
October 8, 2025 · Experience October 8, 2025
Service was okay but pricey
Routine oil change was performed well, but the costs were higher than expected compared to other local shops. Good quality work though.
- Verified customer
Justin Halloran
June 26, 2025 · Experience June 26, 2025
Best Toyota dealer in NY
Bought a Tacoma here last month. Financing was a breeze and the sales team was very patient with all my questions about the trim levels.
- Verified customer
Jack Weaver
May 23, 2025 · Experience May 23, 2025
Helpful staff and good results
Had a recurring electrical issue. They finally tracked it down after a couple of visits. Happy with the resolution even if it took some time.
- Verified customer
Aliah
May 20, 2025 · Experience May 20, 2025
Very disappointed with service wait
Dropped my car off at 8 am, was told it would be ready by noon. Didn't hear a word until 5 pm when I had to call them myself. Unprofessional.
- Verified customer
Eric Donovan
April 13, 2025 · Experience April 13, 2025
Smooth sales and service
Everything about buying my new Camry was efficient. From the test drive with Kevin to the final sign-off, I was treated like a valued customer.
- Verified customer
David McCarty
February 24, 2025 · Experience February 24, 2025
Outstanding service and communication
I brought my car in for a recall and they handled it perfectly. Constant updates and a clean waiting room made the experience great.
- Verified customer
Peter Vance
January 20, 2025 · Experience January 20, 2025
Horrible communication regarding my order
Ordered a part three weeks ago, they kept saying it was coming, then suddenly it was out of stock. Total waste of my time.
- Verified customer
Brenda Vasquez
December 17, 2024 · Experience December 17, 2024
Good service, busy dealership
The service team is very knowledgeable. They fixed my Rav4 issues, but I had to wait a while for a loaner car to become available.